This is a first-pass screening aid for single-phase liquid in a single pipe segment. Gas, two-phase, pump-trip, branched-network, and mitigation-device cases require detailed transient analysis.
Basic Surge Equations:
c = √[1 / (ρ × (1/K + D/(e×E)))]
Rapid: Psurge = c × ρ × V
Slow: Psurge = (2 × L × ρ × V) / ts
Valve Closure Time: Effective closure time is usually the final flow-controlling travel: about 5% for gate, 15% for butterfly, 25% for ball, and 30% for plug valves.
Occasional-Load Factor: ASME B31.3 allows an occasional-load factor of 1.33 for transients lasting < 10 hrs/yr. Use 1.10 for stricter limits.
Cavitation Risk: If down-surge pressure falls below the fluid's vapor pressure, liquid column separation occurs, which can cause severe damage when the column rejoins.
Method & References: Rapid closure uses the Joukowsky equation. Slow closure uses the Michaud / Allievi reduction when the valve closure time is longer than the wave return period. Wave speed uses the Korteweg elastic-pipe model, and the allowable over-pressure limit is screened using an ASME B31.3 occasional-load factor selected by the user.
Recommended values
- Wave speed: a ≈ 1 000–1 400 m/s for water in steel; entrained air or flexible pipe lowers it sharply.
- Rapid closure: If closure time tc < 2L/a the full Joukowsky surge ΔP = ρ·a·Δv develops.
- Slow closure: Surge falls roughly in proportion to (2L/a)/tc — slowing the valve is the first mitigation.
- Mitigation: Add surge vessel / air chamber / relief for long lines or fast trip valves.
Limitations
- Joukowsky basis: Rigid-column / single-pipe estimate — no method-of-characteristics network solve.
- Not included: Column separation, vapour cavitation, and pump-trip transients need a full transient package.
About the standards
- Joukowsky: Water hammer / surge pressure.
- Korteweg: Wave celerity in elastic pipes.
- Michaud-Allievi: Effective surge pressure.